At SleepDoctor.com, we take a comprehensive approach to reviewing mattresses. Our team personally tests each model in different performance areas that affect sleep experiences, then assigns ratings based on our findings. We also base our reviews on pricing, size availability, customer service, and brand reputation. This holistic evaluation process allows us to provide our readers with everything they need to know about today’s leading mattress brands and models.
Below, you’ll find a list of every mattress we’ve reviewed so far along with a detailed explanation of our performance rating criteria. You can also browse our various mattress guides, which feature our top picks for different sleep positions, construction materials, firmness levels, and price ranges.
The sleep position you primarily use plays a major role in which types of mattresses feel most comfortable. Many leading mattresses are designed with balance and versatility in mind, making them suitable for different sleep positions. Others are designed with one specific position in mind. Based on our hands-on tests, we’ve named the best mattresses for each of the three primary sleep positions.
Best Mattress for Side Sleepers
Side sleepers typically prefer their mattresses on the softer side. People who use this position often feel extra pressure on the shoulder and hip they sleep on, so extra cushioning is needed for these two areas. A mattress that contours closely can also promote alignment to prevent aches and pains along the spine.
Best Mattress for Back Sleepers
Unlike side sleeping, back sleeping promotes spinal alignment. This means people who primarily use this position don’t need as much cushioning for their body. At the same time, back sleepers may need extra support to prevent uncomfortable sinkage between the shoulders and hips — especially if they weigh more than 230 pounds. For these reasons, back sleepers tend to prefer medium to medium firm mattresses.
Best Mattress for Stomach Sleepers
We’ve found that stomach sleepers often need firm to extra firm mattresses. This is because lying face down can cause weight from the chest and hips to pull the entire body into the mattress. A supportive surface that keeps the body on an even plane can minimize neck and lower back pain for stomach sleepers.
Every mattress has a unique design, but the vast majority fall into one of five categories based on their materials. Each category is associated with a distinct feel. Some people enjoy the hugging sensation of memory foam mattresses, while others prefer the light contouring and bouncy surface of an all-latex bed. You can also choose from ultra-supportive innersprings, well-balanced hybrids, or airbeds with adjustable firmness levels.
Preferences and Needs
Most people have preferences or needs that define what they need to sleep comfortably. From hot sleepers and people with back pain to those who fall into different weight categories, we’ve identified the best mattresses for a wide range of sleeper types.
Our mattress reviews are based on a comprehensive testing process that evaluates many facets of a bed’s design and performance. We rely on a diverse testing team to conduct these tests and provide objective, thoughtful feedback. Our team includes people who fall into different categories based on body type, sleep position, and general preferences, ensuring our findings are inclusive of all sleepers. The main criteria for our testing is as follows:
- Motion Isolation: When you change sleep positions or get in and out of bed, this movement can transfer to other areas of the mattress. Mattresses that perform well at motion isolation absorb this movement to reduce transfer and prevent other people on the mattress from being disturbed.
- Pressure Relief: Depending on your sleep position, you may experience painful pressure buildup in the shoulders, lower back, or hips. The best mattresses for pressure relief feature materials that cushion pressure-sensitive areas and support systems that prevent you from sinking excessively.
- Temperature Control: A lot of people feel warm when they sleep, and some mattresses can exacerbate this problem by absorbing and trapping heat. Mattresses that offer solid temperature control feature breathable cover materials and internal layers that promote airflow without retaining too much heat.
- Edge Support: Most mattresses buckle a bit when you lie near or sit along their edges, but some are designed with reinforcing support layers that push back against compression and prevent you from sinking too much. Many leading mattresses for edge support are zoned to feel sturdier along the perimeter compared with other areas of the bed.
- Ease of Movement: Some mattresses tend to sink when you move across the surface, which can cause you to feel stuck or trapped. A mattress that facilitates movement won’t sink as much, allowing you to get in and out of bed with relative ease.
- Off-Gassing: After unboxing a new mattress, you may notice a chemical odor. This is known as off-gassing. Most mattresses emit this smell at first, but some models are associated with lingering odors that can be unpleasant for sleeping.
- Sex: We rate mattresses for sex by evaluating how responsive and bouncy they feel. Edge support, ease of movement, and temperature control also come into play.
You’ll find each of our mattress reviews below. To see how two of these models stack up against each other, check out our list of mattress comparisons.