Best Mattress Under $500

Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn a commission.

The cost of a new mattress varies considerably from model to model. That said, most mattresses sold today cost between $900 and $1,700 in a queen size. If you’re mattress shopping on a budget with a price ceiling of $500, then your available options will be somewhat limited — but there are a few standout models within this range that we recommend.

Keep in mind when looking for a new mattress that a steep sticker price does not always mean a high-quality design. By the same token, some mattresses with modest price-points still manage to perform at the same level as many of their more expensive competitors. Understanding the different parts of a mattress and how they function, common materials used to construct mattresses, and mattress performance areas that matter most to sleepers can help you make an informed decision when shopping for a mattress under $500.

Our testing team has personally evaluated hundreds of mattress models, including many that cost less than $500. We’ve selected five top picks based on performance ratings in different categories and feedback from testers in different weight and sleep position groups. Scroll down to review our selections for the best mattresses under $500.

Our Top Picks

Mattress
Pick/Award
Mattress Type
Firmness Level
Starting Price

Best Overall

Hybrid

Firm (7)

Most Comfortable

Foam

Medium Firm (6)

Best for Hot Sleepers

Foam

Firm (7), Medium Firm (6), Medium Firm (6), Medium (5), Medium Soft (4)

Best Pressure Relief

Foam

Medium (5)

Best Cooling

Hybrid

Medium Firm (6)

BEST OVERALL

Allswell Mattress

Mattress Details
  • Firm (7)
  • 100-night sleep trial
  • 10-year warranty
  • Three foam layers cushion and contour the body
  • Coils are zoned to reinforce the perimeter against deep sinkage
See the best prices on the Allswell Mattress

The average hybrid mattress costs at least $1,500 in a queen size, putting this type of mattress out of reach for shoppers with tight budgets. Then there’s the Allswell Mattress, which is priced under $500 in every size up to a queen and barely crosses that threshold for king and California king sizes.

The Allswell features a comfort system with three foam layers over a pocketed coil base. While the mattress has a firm (7) feel, its balanced design that incorporates cushioning materials and a strong support system makes it suitable for a wide range of sleepers.

Thoughtful details elevate the Allswell over many competing hybrids in this price range. The memory foam layer is infused with copper and graphite, both of which have cooling properties, so overheating on the surface won’t be a major issue for most people. The coils are also zoned for extra reinforcement along the perimeter to help you get in and out of bed without sinking too much. Our tests show the Allswell is best suited to back and stomach sleepers who weigh 130 to 230 pounds, as well as side sleepers over 230 pounds.

Shipping is free of charge for all orders within the contiguous U.S. Your Allswell purchase comes with a sleep trial that spans 100 nights, and you’ll also receive a 10-year manufacturer’s warranty should you decide to keep the mattress.  

MOST COMFORTABLE

Siena Mattress

Mattress Details
  • Medium firm (6)
  • 180-night sleep trial
  • 10-year warranty
  • Close yet even contouring for sleepers up to 230 pounds
  • Very good motion isolation for couples
See the best prices on the Siena Mattress

Many sleepers enjoy the cushioning and cradling of memory foam mattresses, but unfortunately, a high-quality memory foam model can cost quite a bit. The Siena Mattress is a good option for shoppers seeking an affordable memory foam mattress with solid long-term value. Built with a memory foam comfort layer over transitional and support layers of dense polyfoam, the Siena contours evenly to the body and alleviates pressure without sacrificing support or ease of movement.

The mattress has a medium firm (6) feel that makes it best suited to side sleepers who weigh up to 230 pounds, plus back and stomach sleepers weighing less than 130 pounds. The memory foam is infused with cooling gel intended to prevent overheating — a common issue associated with this mattress type.

Couples should also be satisfied with the Siena thanks to its excellent motion isolation. The foam layers absorb movement and prevent most motion transfer across the surface, so you and your partner can sleep soundly even when the other person is changing positions or getting up during the night.

Manufacturer’s suggested retail prices for the Siena exceed the $500 mark in most sizes, but the company generally offers generous discounts that drop the price into a much more affordable range. Those who live in the contiguous U.S. also receive free ground shipping, and Siena’s 180-night sleep trial ensures plenty of time for testing out the mattress.

BEST FOR SIDE SLEEPERS

Brooklyn Bedding Chill

Mattress Details
  • Multiple firmness options (4, 5, 6, 7)
  • 120-night sleep trial
  • 10-year warranty
  • Open-cell memory foam infused with cooling gel resists heat buildup
  • Available in 22 sizes
See the best prices on the Brooklyn Bedding Chill

Budget mattress shoppers who primarily sleep on their sides should prioritize close contouring and deep cushioning, as people who use this position often prefer softer mattresses that improve their alignment and reduce pressure along the spine.

Finding a softer mattress under $500 is easier said than done. These models typically contain more layers than firmer ones and carry higher price tags as a result, but there are exceptions to this rule. The Brooklyn Bedding Chill is a great example of a mattress that is well suited to side sleepers and is also affordably priced.

The Chill is available in profiles of 6, 8, 10, 12, or 14 inches. These options also vary in terms of firmness, ranging from firm (7) for the 6-inch model to medium soft (4) for the 14-inch model. Each mattress contains a memory foam comfort layer and one to two support layers of dense polyfoam. The memory foam deeply cushions the shoulders and hips — areas where side sleepers frequently experience pressure buildup — but the support foam stabilizes the mattress and prevents too much sinking. 

The Chill is available in a wide range of sizes to serve different purposes. These include standard mattress sizes, a split California king for couples with adjustable beds, and a handful of options designed specifically for RV owners. Brooklyn Bedding offers free shipping throughout the contiguous U.S. 

BEST PRESSURE RELIEF

Novilla Bliss

Mattress Details
  • Medium (5)
  • 30-night sleep trial
  • 10-year warranty
  • Convoluted polyfoam transitional layer and breathable cover cut down on heat retention
  • Available in 10-inch and 12-inch profiles
See the best prices on the Novilla Bliss

Sleepers who wake up with stiffness or sore spots may need a mattress that reduces pressure along the spine — a common source of early morning discomfort. The Novilla Bliss is an all-foam mattress available in heights of 10 or 12 inches. Both options have medium (5) feels and feature four individual foam layers, including adaptive memory foam and polyfoam comfort layers that closely contour to the body.

All-foam mattresses have a tendency to absorb body heat and sleep uncomfortably warm. The Bliss mitigates this issue with a cooling gel infusion in the top layer intended to dissipate body heat. The polyfoam transitional layer also has a convoluted structure to promote airflow and maintain a cool interior temperature. A cover made of breathable, moisture-wicking rayon derived from bamboo encases the entire mattress. 

The Novilla fared best during our hands-on tests with side and back sleepers who weigh up to 230 pounds and stomach sleepers under 130 pounds.

With the exception of king and California king sizes for the 12-inch version, all available sizes are priced lower than $500. Shoppers can also save some money by bundling their purchase with other Novilla products, and ground delivery is free of charge for all orders within the contiguous U.S.

BEST COOLING

Sweet Night Dreamland

Mattress Details
  • Medium firm (6)
  • 100-night sleep trial
  • 10-year warranty
  • Knit cover and two foam layers soften the surface
  • Pocketed coils stabilize the mattress and reinforce the edges
See the best prices on the Sweet Night Dreamland

If you’re a hot sleeper, chances are you’ll feel most comfortable on an innerspring or hybrid mattress with coil layers that promote airflow and keep the surface cool. Although the cost of these mattresses typically exceeds $500, the Sweet Night Dreamland is one hybrid model that falls below this threshold in most available sizes.

The Dreamland is constructed with layers of memory foam and polyfoam over the coils to provide some surface-level padding. A soft, jacquard-knit cover encases the entire mattress. 

Customers can choose from profiles of 8, 10, or 12 inches depending on how much cushioning they need. All three have medium firm (6) feels that offer strong overall support, but those who prefer deeper contouring should opt for the 10- or 12-inch models. These are also the best options for couples seeking improved motion isolation from their mattress.

Apart from certain locations that the company considers remote, Sweet Night provides free ground shipping to all customers in the contiguous U.S. Returns and exchanges are allowed within 100 nights of the original purchase, and all mattresses are backed by a 10-year warranty.

Our Top Picks