If you’re searching for one of the best memory foam mattresses, look no further than this Puffy mattress review. The Puffy is a medium-firm memory foam mattress that truly is a versatile option for sleepers of all body types and sleep needs. It’s made to offer ample comfort and support, especially for sleepers suffering from back pain.
Puffy is one of the top mattress in a box brands that utilizes memory foam to make a supportive and comfortable sleep experience. Puffy took traditional memory foam and improved upon it, creating a bed using their own special types of foam. The result is a mattress that’s soft enough for side sleepers to enjoy, but firm enough to provide the support back and stomach sleepers need.
Working with the mattress testing experts at Mattress Advisor, The Sleep Doctor, Michael Breus, Ph.D. provides expertise in this Puffy mattress review. The Puffy underwent rigorous testing at the Mattress Advisor test lab based out of Raleigh, NC. It was analyzed via a 14 point test critiquing its performance, construction, and overall benefits on a scale of 1-10, 10 being the perfect score.
If you’re a side sleeper trying to avoid discomfort in your hips, or a multi-positional sleeper avoiding back pain, read on to how the Puffy can be the best new mattress for you.
Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission.
Puffy Mattress Review: Pros and Cons
The Puffy Is Best For…
- Multi positional sleepers, who like a variety of sleep styles
- Couples who split a bed
- Shoppers looking to maximize their value
- Sleepers who love the cushioning, contouring feel of a memory foam mattress
Puffy Might Not Be Best For…
- Sleepers who want something more plush
- Sleepers who prefer the feel and support of an innerspring coil system
Features Highlighted in the Puffy Mattress Review
As you’re assessing your Puffy mattress review, there are a few key factors to keep in mind.
The Puffy mattress scored a 9/10 for responsiveness, due in part to its three layers of memory foam, which provide the kind of cushioning feel that all-foam beds are known for. These foam layers have a tendency to “bounce back” whenever being compressed. So no matter what sleep position you choose, or even if you like to move around between your back, stomach, and side, the Puffy will cushion and support you no matter what.
Memory foam has been around since its invention by NASA in the 1960’s, but Puffy uses its own special form of memory foam that’s perfect for all kinds of sleepers. Memory foam can often absorb body heat and confine it, and as a result you wake up feeling hot. Puffy invented its own “cooling cloud foam” that is more eco-friendly, doesn’t use harmful chemicals, and most importantly, helps keep your body temperature in check. While this foam absorbs excess heat, the cooling memory foam works hard to keep your body sweat-free (scoring an 8/10 in cooling during Mattress Advisor testing).
In most cases, memory foam isn’t the first pick for sleepers who want a little extra back support. This is because memory foam has more give to it, and many stomach and back sleepers want a firmer mattress. The Puffy offers solid spinal alignment, scoring an 8.75 out of 10 in tests. So besides cushioning your body, it also will make sure to keep your back supported and comfortable.
For couples who share a bed together, motion isolation is always a concern. Essentially, this tells you whether you’ll disrupt your partner when you move around to get comfortable or get up to use the bathroom. In our testing, we find that the Puffy mattress scores through the roof in this category, achieving a nearly perfect 9.25 out of 10.
“I often think that motion transfer has saved many a relationship” says Dr. Breus. “When people are moving or getting up at different times (or in the middle of the night), having excellent motion transfer becomes a critical feature, so that the bed movement (from the person moving or getting up) do NOT awaken the sleeper!”
The Best Sleep Positions for the Puffy Mattress
Before you toss out your old mattress, it’s helpful to think about your own sleeping habits and comfort preferences, including your default sleep position. Your posture can have a significant impact on the quality and comfort of your sleep, and it’s important to seek the best mattress to accentuate healthy posture. According to our Puffy mattress review, how does this bed stack up?
The classic, contouring feel of memory foam is well-suited for side sleepers, especially those who like to feel as though they’re being hugged to sleep at night. Our Puffy mattress review found that this bed helps side sleepers’ spines by maintaining a healthy alignment, which minimizes the risk of morning aches and pains. In the spine alignment portion of the Mattress Advisor test, the Puffy scored an 8.75 out of 10. It was tested in all sleep styles to ensure healthy posture was being achieved in every aspect. One of those sleep positions is side sleeping. Usually, side sleepers need to watch out for is pressure relief, mainly because their hips and shoulders are pressing their weight down as they rest. The Puffy scored an 8 out of 10 in the Mattress Advisor pressure relief test, so side sleepers will enjoy sleeping on it with minimal pressure or pain.
Our Puffy mattress review found that this bed’s medium firmness makes it a good pick for back sleepers, who will be able to maintain a natural spinal curvature without feeling like they’re sinking too far into the bed. Because sleeping on your back means your spine is bearing down into the bed, it’s important that it has the support it needs. Spinal alignment is an important consideration here, and one where Puffy has down pat (8.75/10).
Very similar to back sleepers, the medium-firm feel and high spinal alignment score (an 8.75/10) makes the Puffy a good pick for stomach sleepers, who will get the support they need without much risk of sinkage. Sinking often leads to your spine moving into an unhealthy alignment. Memory foam mattresses are usually notorious for being too soft, but the Puffy steps up to be one of the best firm mattresses.
Those who switch between sleep positions are called combination sleepers, and they typically benefit from a mattress that can adjust and adapt to their movements. Our Puffy mattress review found it performed exceedingly well in responsiveness testing, landing a 9 out of 10.
Puffy Mattress Review: What Else to Know
There are a few additional categories in which the Puffy mattress shines, starting with edge support, ranking an 8.75 out of 10 in testing. Backed by a lifetime warranty, the Puffy is made to stand the test of time. You can trust that it won’t sag, and it will maintain its shape and support for years.
One extra perk the Puffy offers is that it comes with a stain-resistant mattress cover, making your sleeping surface incredibly easy to keep clean. This is especially a bonus if you have kids!
More About Puffy
There’s more to Puffy than their comfortable mattress products. Before making a purchasing decision, consider just a few important details about the Puffy shopping experience.
Puffy beds all come with a 101-night sleep trial. That means from the day your mattress shows up on your doorstep, you’ll have 101 nights to break it in, try it out, and ensure it’s to your liking. If it’s not what you hoped for, you can return the mattress within that timeframe and get your money back.
Mattress Advisor testing confirms the Puffy to be made with high-quality materials, and designed to last. The manufacturers clearly have a lot of faith in the longevity of their product, because they back it with an impressive lifetime warranty.
If you do decide to return the mattress within the sleep trial period, you can arrange to have Puffy haul it off and donate it to a local charity. There is no cost to this mattress removal service.
Made in the United States
If you’re eager for solid USA craftsmanship, all Puffy products are assembled here in America.
Other Mattresses Sold by Puffy
Not sure if the original Puffy mattress is right for you? The company makes a few different mattresses that might be better fitted for your sleeping position as well as for your budget.
The Puffy Lux mattress is the high-end version of the Puffy original. One of the best mattresses for side sleepers, it offers a lot of the same features and benefits, including the lifetime warranty and the excellent pressure point relief (scored a 9.5/10 here). What sets it apart is that it has an extra layer of foam, meaning it has four total: A gel top layer, two dense support layers, and a durable base layer. That’s a lot of memory foam, and many sleepers will love this luxurious construction. However, due to the plusher feel of the bed, it may not work quite as well for stomach sleepers.
The Puffy Royal is the premium option Puffy has available. That means it has the steepest price point, but it also comes with some winsome bells and whistles, including a removable mattress cover, support for the back and neck, and a full 365-night sleep trial. It’s another mid-range option on the firmness scale, which means it should work well for most sleepers.
Final Thoughts from Our Puffy Mattress Review
As you seek the perfect mattress, there are a lot of factors to keep in mind, including your budget, your sleep style, and more. Thanks to its universally appealing support foam, its generous warranty, its reasonable price point, and its middling firmness level, the Puffy is a great overall bargain for all that it offers. Puffy’s “cloud foam” feel is an especially good option for couples and for those seeking back pain relief. Overall, if you’re looking for the best memory foam mattress for all sleep styles and keep you cool, the Puffy is here to help.
Sources for this article:
Chow, D. “Everyday Tech From Space: ‘Memory Foam’ for the Masses.” Space.com, February 7, 2011. https://www.space.com/10783-space-spinoff-technology-memory-foam.html
Puffy. “How It’s Made.” Puffy.com, October 9, 2020. https://puffy.com/pages/how-its-made